Your responses to the Act I questions were excellent! I am proud that you thoughtfully considered each one of the questions and put time and effort into your responses. I know that your Act II questions will be even better than your last responses, so I am very pleased at the way that we are traveling.
PLEASE ENSURE THAT ALL RESPONSES ARE IN COMPLETE SENTENCES.
Keep it up!
Parsons
Scene 1 -
1. What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Scene 2 -
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Scene 3 -
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
Scene 4 -
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4.
51 comments:
Brutus' said that he had no personal reason to strike at Caesar, only the best interest of the people, meaning he thought that it was the best for the people of Rome. "It's the faction (group of people) that wants to kill Caesar." he also said that if they crowned him, that they would be giving him the power to do damage.
act 2, scene 2
1. It shows that he is only doing this for the good of rome.
2. no it doesn't, because he is scared that power will change his friend he is a good friend and is scared power will change his friendship with Caesar
3. I think he did not take the oath because he was still unsure about killing Caesar
4. She confronts him about having a secret
act 2 scene 2
1. The storm represents the jumbling feelings about Caesar in rome
2. because Decius convinces him that Calphurnia's dream was a good omen and a sign of luck and love from the roman people.
3. Because he is upset that he is going to betray Caesar
act 2 scene 3
1. It foreshadows brutus killing caesar and shows that fate is acting in brutus' favor
act 2 scene 4
1. She acts as though she knows brutus' plans to kill Caesar. She is worried, and this feeling increases when the soothsayer enters.
ct 2 Questions
Amanda Harris
2nd period
Mr. Parsons Class
Scene 1:
1) Brutus' soliloquy shows us that the only reason he is going to kill Caesar is to help Rome. He stated that he didn't have any personal motives for killing him, but just that he was trying to better Rome.
2) Yes, my views of Brutus before hearing his motives were that I thought he was just a follower. That he was just going to do it because he was told to. But, now I see Brutus as being a loyal follower. He is still being a loyal follower. He is still being a true to Pompey, the former ruler and leader of Rome. I also believe that he is easily mislead, and very gullible, because he believes that he is doing this for the sake of Rome. But, that is not true, Cassius has him believing that killing Caesar is what is best for Rome.
3) Brutus denies taking the oath because he said that their cause would be strong enough to bind them together. Therefore they did not need to swear an oath.
4) Portia realized that Brutus had been acting strange. So, she confronted him about it. She said that she should know what his problems because she was his wife. Portia also stated that she would keep his secrets if he would just confide in her.
Scene 2:
1) The weather at the beginning of scene two is made know that there is thunder and lightning. A raging storm is on its way. And storms are not usually a good sign. Bad things are approaching.
2) Caesar decides to go out because of Decius' comment. "... If you shall send them word you will not come, their minds may change. Besides, it were a mock Apt to be rendered for someone to say..." ".. I Caesar hide himself, shall they not whisper, 'Lo, Caesar is afraid'?"
3) Brutus is sad at the end of the scene because Caesar believe that Brutus is his friend and that he loves him. And Brutus knows that he has no idea that he is about to be betrayed by people that he thought he could trust.
Scene 3:
1) Artemidorius' letter represents foreshadowing because in his letter he tells Caesar that Brutus does not love him. And he also tells him to beware of all the people around him if he is not immortal.
Scene 4:
1) Portia sends Lucius to the senate house. She is acting really frantic about everything. She says that she has the mind of a man, but only a woman's strength. How hard is it for women to keep secrets? She then told him to go and see if his master looked well. She had tried to keep him from going to the senate house, but Caesar had not listened. She is worried about whether or not Caesar is alright.
ACT 2, SCENE 1
1. He is torn and worried. He likes Caesar as a friend, and is saddened that he has to kill him. He however loves Rome more than he does his friend, and although he does not want to, he will do what he believes is best for his city.
2. I personally feel that Brutus is a good person, and I like him. But, his motives are false. I suppose that in his mind he is justified, but in reality, the murder of Caesar is not truly for the good of Rome, and therefore is not right.
3. He does not want to take an oath for something that is worrying and corrupting him. And perhaps one that he may not be able to keep.
4. She pleads with him to tell her what is troubling him. Saying that she loves him and has been a good wife that deserves to know her husband's thoughts and secrets.
ACT 2, SCENE 2
1. It is bleak weather, with storms and such. It signifies the worry of everyone around Caesar. Brutus and his conflicting thoughts, Calphurnia and her worries for her husband, among others.
2. He says that the Gods are testing him, to see if he is a coward or not, and that he should travel into the city. He reasons by saying whatever the gods have planned will happen regardless of where he is.
3. He is reminded how Caesar feels about him, that he and the rest of his company are all good friends. He is sad that he must kill his friend, and betray him and his trust.
ACT 2, SCENE 3
1. He names certain people, saying that some, such as Brutus are treacherous, and do not love him, and others he has wronged and they have aims to kill him. And, at the end, they show they believe in things such as fate when the letter states, "I pray the mighty gods defend you!"
ACT 2, SCENE 4
1. She has shown from earlier scenes that she loves her husband, and that she is a strong determined woman. Her actions in this scene help to further support that. She is putting things in to place and finding information, to help Brutus succeed in his endeavor. Now that's a woman. Reminds me of Sarah Palin.
Scene 1
1.He doesn’t want to kill Caesar but for the sake of the people he believes it is right. His ancestors said that a king would be bad for Rome. His motive was the people and that he is physically and not mentally able.
2.I believe that Brutus is still a good person. He is just doing what he thinks is right for Rome and its people. His motives are that the people look up to him and believe in him so he wants to keep his people safe. He has justified himself as an honorable person who has a consensus even though it is probably the right thing to do for Rome’s people.
3.He didn’t want to take an oath because he said that if the corruption of the current time isn’t enough to motivate us then we should go back to bed. He believed they had a cause to make cowards into brave men, for if they let him rein Brutus said, he would kill us all.
4.Portia wants him to tell her everything. She begged him and told him that they took vows that made them into one person. She begged to tell her everything. About the strange people who visited and why he couldn’t sleep. However he didn’t say a thing.
Scene 2
1.The weather reflects the foreshadowing of that something bad was going to happen all the thunder and lightning, bad omens.
2.One of the people who are in on the plan to kill Caesar tells him that they were going to offer him a real crown. Then if he didn’t come then they might change their mind and say that he wasn’t right for the crown because it would make him look weak.
3.He is sad because he knows he has to kill Caesar but it’s hard on him. Caesar was good to him but for the peoples sake he knew he had to kill him.
Scene 3
1.The letter tells everything that’s going to happen. The letter tells about people plotting to kill and how his own men are backstabbing him and to watch himself.
Scene 4
1.Portia tells Lucius to go to the Senate and tell Caesar about the letter. She says to tell him to watch himself that they want to kill. She is afraid for Caesar’s sake that they want to kill him. She told Lucius to watch him and then come back.
Act 2 Scene 1:
1. In Brutus' revealing soliloquy, he reveals his intentions and thoughts on murdering Caesar. Brutus does not have a quarrel with Caesar personally, but he does not want Caesar crowned. Brutus has the intent to kill Caesar for the greater good of the people. Brutus is truly loyal to Rome and does not want to see it perish.
2. No this does not change my view of Brutus. He seemed like a knowledgeable and just person in the first place, and he is showing this in his soliloquy. Brutus is being a true citizen and defender of Rome, and he does not mind getting his hands dirty in order to keep Rome in check. I believe that the murder is justified, because Caesar does not seem like a fitting ruler. And with the support of the people, Brutus has reason to commit this crime.
3. Brutus does not wish to take an oath, because he believes there is already a just cause and enough reason to motivate Rome to fight against this injustice. He does not need some oath or promise to make him do the right thing. He is an honorable and virtuous man, and he seeks to uphold that.
4. Portia seems to be offended in a way. She sees it that Brutus' behavior is rude and uncalled for. She has seen a noticeable change in Brutus' behavior and she wishes that Brutus would either deal with the problem, or at least tell her what is going on.
Act 2 Scene 2:
1. The thunder and lightning outside reflects what is going to happen soon. The storm is signifying that there will be conflict soon.
2. Caesar is showing a defining act of bravery, as he does not care to face death. Caesar knows what is going to happen, and he acknowledges the inevitable. He wishes to confront his conflicts head on and deal with them himself.
3. Brutus is saddened by Caesars actions. Brutus enjoys Caesar as a friend, and loathes having to do this deed. Brutus may be having second thoughts on this whole ordeal.
Act 3 Scene 3:
1. This letter just adds more to the foreshadowing. Us readers are almost certain that Caesar will be murdered now, and this only helps me think that. This also gives us a hint that its one of Caesars insiders, because of the, "A sense of security opens the door to conspiracy", line.
TO BE CONTINUED
Act2 Scene1
1.) Brutus really doesn’t want to kill him and that he is not doing so for himself. He is going to kill Caesar because he of his city and his people. Brutus’ motive is to make his people proud and not to further suffer. He knows that Caesar’s emotions get the better of him and does not wish for him to rule.
2.) This changes the way I view Brutus in a way because I thought he only wanted to kill Caesar because of Cassius. I think that his views for killing Caesar can be considered justified, and not. In the justified manner he wants to kill him for his people, which is a huge sacrifice. On the other hand he would have never had these ideas in the first place if it had been for Cassius.
3.) Brutus does not want to take this oath. He said it is for cowardly and overly cautious men.
4.) Portia thinks that Caesar is not really sick because if he were he would take something to get better. She is almost to the point of anger because he will not tell her his secrets. She’s also angry because she thinks that Caesar thinks that she is not as strong as man; that she is like the rest of her sex.
Act2 Scene2
1.) The weather fits the story because of the weather in Calphurnia’s dream, which was rainy with much lightning and thunder. This weather usually sets the backdrop of something horrible coming, or in this novel, the death of Caesar.
2.) This is because Decius tells Caesar that if he doesn’t go he will not receive his crown. Also because Decius said Portia’s ream meant good things.
3.) Brutus is sad because he knows that he is only pretending to be friends with Caesar. He feels like he is using him.
Act2 Scene3
1.) He calls out certain names such as Brutus and says they do not love him. He says they are evil and aim to kill him. They show in the end that they believe in fate and say that they pray the big Gods protect him.
Act2 Scene4
1.) Portia has shown earlier in the novel that she loves Caesar. Portia is a very strong woman and different from the female sex. She digs and finds a bunch of information for her husband and his determined to help him. Portia is a very strong determined woman who is putting people in there place.
Act 2, Scene 1
1. What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Brutus said that he had no personal reason to want to kill Caesar. He thinks he is doing it for the good of Rome. Brutus thinks that Caesar is going to abuse his power and do damage toward Rome. Brutus said, But everyone knows that an ambitious young man uses humility to advance himself, but when he reaches the top, he turns his back on his supporters and reaches for the skies while scorning those who helped him get where he is." He means that Caesar will forgot about everybody who helped him get to where he is, and he will turn his back on his people. So, Brutus wants to kill Caesar.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Yes, this changes my opinion on Brutus very much. When the play started out, I thought that Brutus was a nice guy who went along with everybody. Now I think that Brutus is very much like Cassius. The reasons that Brutus has to kill Caesar, do not make sense to me. Nobody is for sure if Caesar would be a great leader or not. Therefore Brutus is not justified.
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Brutus did not want to take an oath with the other conspirators because he says that if the bad things that are going on in Rome do not motivate them enough, then nothing will.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
She believes that Brutus is hiding something from her, which he is, and she told Brutus that she does not feel like a wife, she feels like a whore. Portia said that because, she feels that Brutus should be able to tell her everything that goes on.
Act 2, Scene 2
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
The weather reflects foreshadowing. In the play it starts raining, and it is also thundering. Usually to the reader, that means that something bad is going to happen.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
Caesar goes out despite of his wife's dream, because Decius interprets the dream that Calphurnia had. She took the dream in a way that something bad was going to happen to Caesar, but Decius sees it in another way. Decius talks Caesar into going out.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Brutus is sad because Caesar says, Good friends, go in and have some wine with me. And we'll leave together, like friends." Brutus took this as Caesar being like, yea whatever, we really are not that close.
Act 2, Scene 3
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
The letter represents foreshadowing by, making that readers think that this note is going to get to Caesar, before it is to late. Fate is coming into this by letting Caesar know that his death may be coming soon and he needs to do something about it.
Act 2, Scene 4
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4
In scene 4, Portia is acting very concerned for her husband, Brutus, and what he is about to do. First, she sent Lucius to see what was going on and to return immediately, then she is questioning the soothsayer about what he thinks is going to happen. I am sure that Portia has an idea about what it about to take place, but she just is not 100% sure.
Act 2, Scene 1
1. Brutus' soliloquy shows, Brutus' wants to kill Caesar not because of something personal but to better Rome.
2. No my views for him did not change. He is a very gullible person, and is mislead easily by Cassius. I have always thought this. He believes he's doing the right thing for Rome. I think his manner in killing Caesar is Justified, but on the other hand he wouldn't feel this way if it wasn't for Cassius.
3. He doesn't want to take the oath because he feels that if the cause isn't strong enough, than way bother going through with it.
4. She confronted him about keeping a secret form her. She told him that his secrets were safe with her.
Scene 2
1. At the beginning a storm is coming through which usually leads to no good. The thunder and lighting means there is danger ahead.
2. He decides to go anyway because of the comment Decius made. He told Caesar that they may changed their minds and people will whisper that Caesar is afraid.
3. Brutus is sad because Caesar tells him that he believes he is his friend and loves him. Brutus knows that himself and other people are about to betray him.
Scene 3
1. Artemidorius' letter represents foreshadowing because, he is telling Caesar that Brutus does not love him and to watch out for the people around him. he tells him that they are evil.
Scene 4
1. She sent, Lucius to the senate house to report back to her how Caesar looked. She is very worried about him. She says she has a mind of a men but a women's strength. She is very different from other woman. She is putting things in place to find information. I think she knows something very bad is going to happen.
Scene 1 -
1. What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Brutus says that he has no personal reason to kill Caesar but it would only be in the best interest of the people.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Yes this changes my view on Brutus. I thought Brutus was Caesar’s friend. Brutus wants what’s best for the people. He doesn’t want to kill Caesar but then again he doesn’t want Caesar to become King. I think Brutus has good intentions and he believes that he has to kill Caesar for the people. I think he could handle it a better way than to kill Caesar. No I do not think that he is justified.
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Brutus doesn’t want to take an oath because he does not want the oath to be broken. He is afraid that one of the men will back out if an oath is made.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Portia is worried about Brutus at the end of the scene.
Scene 2 -
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
The weather is bad in the play. It is lighting and thundering, showing a dark scene, murder is approaching. The weather goes along with what is about to happen in the play.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
Caesar says that the dreams have only looked at his back not at his face. He says there is no way of avoiding what the gods want to happen.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Brutus says “ That every “like” is not the same, O Caesar, the heart of Brutus earns to think upon.” I think Brutus is sad becuas ethey are about to kill Caesar.
Scene 3 -
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
It represents foreshadowing by warning Caesar that he is about to be murdered and telling him who to stay away from. The role of fate is that he is trying to save Caesar.
Scene 4 -
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4
Portia is frantic and worried. She sends Lucius to Brutus to find out what is happening. Portia talks to the soothsayer to find out what is going on.
ACT 2, SCENE 1
1. What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Brutus said, "The only way is to kill Caesar. I have no personal reason to strike at him—only the best interest of the people. He wants to be crowned. The question is, how would being king change him? Evil can come from good, just as poisonous snakes tend to come out into the open on bright sunny days—which means we have to walk carefully. If we crown him, I have to admit we'd be giving him the power to do damage." By this he means that he has no personal interest in killing Caesar, he just wants to help the people. He also thinks that crowning Caesar will only turn him evil and give him power to do wrong things.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
I don't see Brutus as being a murderer or being someone who is jealous for power. I think that he was just easily persuaded by Cassius, and now he thinks that it is only right that Caesar is taken from power. Brutus said, "But 'tis a common proof that lowliness is young ambition's ladder, whereto the climber upward turns his face. But when he once attains the upmost round, he then unto the ladder turns his back, looks in the clouds, scorning the base degrees by which he did ascend." He says that everyone knows that people who are given power then turn their back on the people who have supported them. He never thought this of Caesar before, and who is to say that Brutus wouldn't do the same? I can understand that he wants to help the people of Rome, but I still don't find him justified in killing someone to do so.
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
He said that they should have enough motivation already, and that oaths are for cowards. He also said that they should all be able to trust each other, therefore, they don't need oaths.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
She acts very concerned about Brutus. He claims that he just isn't feeling well, but she knows otherwise. She says that he has some secret that is bothering him and begs him to tell her. She also acts angry that Brutus will not trust her. She thinks it's because she's a woman.
ACT 2, SCENE 2
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
There are a lot of weird things going on in the night. There are storms, a lioness giving birth in the street, and graves "yawned and yielded up their dead." I think it is reflecting the conflicts that are going on right now, and it is also an omen of all the bad things that are to come.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
Decius convinces him that his wife interpreted the dream wrong. He also tells Caesar that if he doesn't go, they might change their mind about crowning him.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
He is upset that he has to betray Caesar. They used to be friends, and now he is plotting his murder. He feels bad because Caesar has no idea what is going on.
ACT 2, SCENE 3
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
He names off the people who he thinks Caesar shouldn't trust, which are all the people plotting to kill him. Fate comes into the work because these people believe in the gods. Artemidorius said, "I pray that the mighty gods defend you!"
ACT 2, SCENE 4
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4.
She acts very worried about the things to come involving her husband. She sents Lucius to the senate house straightaway and acts very frantic about it. She also questions the soothsayer about what he thinks is going to occur. She has an idea of what is going on, but she isn't sure. In the previous scenes, it shows that she is a strong woman who loves her husband. This scene supports that even further.
act ll scene i
1.What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
brutus dont actually want to kill or hurt Julius Caesar for no reason but brutus will do it because he thinks its best for the citizens of Rome.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Yes it does change the way i see brutus because i thought he was a caring guy and supported Caesar but him wanting to kill Caesar over something he knows nothing about,he dont know if Ceaser will be a good king or not so that makes him a judging person.
3.Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
I think that Brutus wants to that the oath because he believes he dont need a oath that makes him doing what he feels is the right thing to do.
4.How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
portia reacts to brutus behavior like she is concerned about what was going on in his head and why he is acting so different.
act ll scene ii
1.How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
the weather reflects the play because its setting the plot of the story when its thundering and raining its telling that bad events its building up and could happen.
2.Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
he keeps on going because he thinks that the gods are testing him to see if he is a coward and that cowards will died many times befor thier deaths and he dont want that to heppen to him.
3.Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
he is sad because Caesar tells him to go in and have a drink with him but Caesar has no idea what is really bout to heppen, that Brutus is planning to kill him.
act ll scene iii
1.How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
it is foreshadowing because the letter is telling Ceaser that his fate is coming soon and its giving him a headup before it really does happen.
act 2 scene v
1.Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4
Portia's actions in scene v is she is very scared and want to know what is going on with her husband Brutus. she asked the soothsayer and had Lucius go out and try to find out what is going on.
Alex Lanning: 5th period: Act 2
Scene 1:
1. What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
-Brutus’ soliloquy expresses multiple reasons to eliminate Caesar. He thinks it’s what the people want and need. Secondly, he believes Caesar will let the power go to his head and only inflict damage upon the citizens. “That at his will he may do danger with.” Lastly, Brutus knows from earlier rulers that once an honest man reaches the top, he turns his back on his supporters and uses people to get where he wants.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
-This doesn’t necessarily change my views on Brutus, I didn’t think he was much of a strong person anyway. It does emphasize his weak characteristics such as having no backbone, and letting others (Cassius) make decisions for him. Also, his reasons do not seem justified. I agree that some people do let the thought of control overcome their morals but he hasn’t been given a reason to think that about Julius.
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
-Brutus actually stands up and rebels against taking oath. He believes that the bond among the men should be held together by willingness to carryout the plans.He creates irony when he explains that promises should not be broken (because he is backstabbing Caesar) and that an oath isnt needed. “Swear priests and cowards and men cautelous, Old feeble carrions and such suffering souls.”
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
-Brutus’ wife Portia was very observative when he got up in the middle of the night. She noticed something was wrong and confronted him about it. She played the guilt trick and insisted that if he was noble, he would tell her what’s wrong because she is his trustworthy wife, not his whore. Portia saw right through Brutus when he lied about being sick. She explained her ability to keep a secret when she said, “Tell me your counsels. I will not disclose 'em. I have made strong proof of my constancy.”
Scene 2:
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
-The fact that the weather is very horrible and unpredictable during all this goes hand in hand with Cassius’ actions. The intense rain and strong winds adds even more tension to what is already produced by Brutus, Calphurnia and others.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
-Caesar’s wife, Calphurnia, was very protective of him when he wanted to go out into the streets. She insisted that he stay home, but his servant Decius suggested otherwise. Decius said people will talk of his cowardliness and draw conclusions that he was too chicken to come out and face everyone.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
-Brutus began to realize that Caesar has much trust in him and sees him as a very good friend. In a way, Brutus wanted to keep that bond, but he knows he must follow through with the plan.
Scene 3:
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
-He warns Caesar of many people and says they have one thought: to kill you. This is a great example of foreshadowing and it lets the reader know that death is in the future. In opposition to that, the fact that Caesar now knows of the plans produces a feeling of fate in the sense that he can be extra cautious and possibly prevent his murder.
Scene 4:
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4.
-Portia, Brutus’ wife, becomes very nosy in this scene. She turns Lucious (her servant) into a spy and orders him to visit the Capital. While there, his job is to see if her husband and Caesar are well. Quickly after her conversation with Lucious, the soothsayer appeared and she immediately began to pry him for knowledge. After realizing that Brutus is invlolved in a plan to kill Caesar, she informs Lucious of the happening and insists that he needs to get the scoop for her.
English Honors II - Act II – Tyler Hurst
Act II, Scene ii
1. What does Brutus’ soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Answer: It shows us that Brutus has only one motive for killing Caesar: to preserve the Roman government. “O Rome, I make thee promise / If the redress will follow, thou receivest / Thy full petition at the hand of Brutus!” In these three lines, Brutus swears to give Rome justice. Unlike Cassius, Brutus sees Caesar as a threat to Rome, not a threat to himself. Brutus is a man of honor and doesn’t want to kill Caesar to obtain more power like Cassius does. Through these actions, one can conclude that Brutus is an honorable man, with integrity, character, and an outstanding sense of patriotism.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Answer: Brutus’ soliloquy does not change the manner in which I view Brutus. The soliloquy allows the reader to have a better understanding of Brutus and his inner thoughts concerning the events taking place in Rome. Although uncertain at first, Brutus has finally come to the realization that the Roman government can only continue to exist through the death of Caesar. He also reasserts that he is only committing such an act to preserve the empire and protect the people of Rome. Brutus shows his integrity by not having any personal motives for killing Caesar like Cassius does. Brutus is justified in killing Caesar because he represents a direct threat to the Roman Republic.
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Answer: Brutus is against taking an oath because he feels that an oath shouldn’t be the motivation for carrying out the assassination of Caesar. He says that only men whom you wouldn’t trust anyways would try and swear an oath. He thinks the motivation for killing Caesar should be the people, not an oath between powerful noblemen.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus’ strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Answer: She is very suspicious and feels as if she is obligated to counsel him about his troubles. She actually gets on her knees and begs him to tell her what’s troubling him. Portia thinks that since she is his wife, he should tell her. I also think her concern for Brutus is legitimate and that she truly cares for her husband.
Act II, Scene ii
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
Answer: The thunder and the lightning serves as a fitting background to the events taking place. Cassius and his followers are plotting to kill Caesar and the lightning shattering the skies is also a warning to Caesar. The interpretation can go both ways.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife’s dream?
Answer: He is afraid he will be mocked by the senators who are suppose to give the crown to Caesar that very day. If he’d stayed home as his wife suggested, it would make it seem as if Calphurnia had power of Caesar.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Answer: Brutus has is sad because he has at last decided Caesar must die for the sake of Rome. Brutus liked Caesar and could consider him a friend. Brutus, however, knows he must act like a friend, instead of being a true friend because he must kill Caesar.
Act II, Scene iii
1. How does Artemidorious’ letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing?
Answer: The letter foreshadows all the people who will kill Caesar and Artemidorious puts the situation in the hands of the gods. Artemidorious says that if Caesar doesn’t read the letter, fate is on the side of Brutus and the traitors. “ If you read this, O Caesar, thou mayst live / If not, the fates with traitors do contrive.”
Act II, Scene iv
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia’s actions in Scene 4.
Portia is has caught on to what Brutus and the other conspirators are up to. She is not yet certain about their course of actions, but she is shaken by the thought of harming Caesar. She is very worried, so much that she sends her servant on an errand to the Capitol for little reason at all, but to observe Brutus and Caesar. She also questions the soothsayer about the possibility of something happening to Caesar. Portia has proven that she is smart and clever by catching on to what the conspirators are planning.
Scene 1 -
1. What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Answer- Brutus is afraid that when Caesar comes into power, he is receiving power that will enable him to do damage. He explains his motives as when rulers want to get crowned, they end up abusing their power. He wants what is best for the people of Rome.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Answer- These ideas and motives from Brutus makes me think less of him. If he feels this way about rulers, than he would not want anyone to come into power. I think he is finding a motive to kill Caesar to satisfy Cassius.
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Answer- Brutus thinks that an oath isn't need because their motives are strong enough. Brutus also says that, "Swear priests and cowards and men cautelous." He means that swears, or oaths, are for cowards and overly cautious men.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Answer- Portia is very concerned about Brutus not acting noble. She is worried and somewhat angry about him not sharing his secret with her.
Scene 2 -
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
Answer- The weather in this scene is thunder and lightning. During this time, Calphurnia has had a dream about Caesar being murdered. Also a sacrifice is being performed and it is time for Caesar to take his crown, foreshadowing bad events to happen while he takes the crown.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
Answer- Decius interprets Calphurnia's dream as a good thing. He says the dream means that men will want to have approval of Caesar's holy blood. Decius also explains to Caesar that the senate may think that Caesar is afraid to take the crown and that there would be a chance that he would not get it.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Answer- Brutus is sad because he is only pretending to be friends with Caesar. He knows that people are planning to kill Caesar.
Scene 3 -
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
Answer- It represents foreshadowing because the letter explains to Caesar who all is planning a conspiracy towards him. The role of fate is shown by Artemidorius saying that he prays that the gods will defend Caesar.
Scene 4 -
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4.
Answer- Portia is learning about Brutus' plan. She asks Lucius to run to the senate and to pay attention to how Caesar acts. Portia also asks the Soothsayer if he has heard of any actions plotted against Caesar. She has found out Brutus' secret and is trying to warn the people and to help Caesar. She explains that she has a man's mind but only has a woman's strength. She is warning people that Caesar will fall because she cannot do anything about it by herself.
Scene I
1. Brutus is not killing Caesar out of spite, but rather out of fear he will become too powerful. As he says, “ I have not known when his affections swayed more than his reason. But ‘tis a common proof that lowliness is young ambition’s ladder, whereto the climber upward turns his face.” Brutus believes, that although Caesar has never let his emotions get the best of him, his power may get the best of him and he will turn his back on his supporters. Brutus wants to stop him before he dangerously tries to abuse his power.
2. Brutus’ soliloquy makes me respect him more. Brutus is loyal, honorable, and wise. He is plotting against Caesar, not out of jealousy like the other conspirators, but because he is worried about the safety of Rome. I believe he is justified, because he is just trying to do what is best for the entire country and ensure that Caesar’s potential tyranny does not occur, even if it means killing one of his close friends.
3. Brutus does not want to swear on an oath, because he believes only people you would not trust need to swear on an oath. He also says, that he knows no one will back down, so it is simply not necessary.
4. Portia confronts Brutus about his strange behavior, and begs him to tell her his secret. When he does not, she is offended, saying, “Swell I but in the suburbs of your good pleasure? If it be no more, Portia is Brutus’ harlot not his wife.” She means, if you will not even tell me what is going on, then you do not think very much of me as your wife.
Scene II
1. Violent storms that are taking place signify the nearby assassination of Caesar.
2. Decius comes to Caesar’ s home to take him to the Senate House while Caesar explains he cannot go due to Calphurnia’s dream. Decius consoles him, saying the dream should of Caesar as a fountain with blood coming out, should not be interpreted as a bad omen, but Decius consoles him, saying it was actually an omen of his great power that is yet to come. Decius goes on to say that the crown was going to be offered to Caesar. Therefore, Caesar goes ahead to the Senate House.
3. Caesar says, “Good friends go in and taste some wine with me. And we, like friends, will straightaway go together.” Brutus says, “That every “like” is not the same, O Caesar, the heart of Brutus earns to think upon.” The fact that Caesar wants to have wine with his “friends”, makes Brutus sad, because Caesar is unaware of the actions the conspirators will soon carry out.
Scene III
1. Artemidorus’ letter warns Caesar of the conspirators plot to turn against him. This foreshadows the impending fate of Caesar that is soon to follow. Artemidorus also goes on to say, “If thou read this, O Caesar, thou mayst live. If not, the Fates with the traitors do contrive.” This means, if Caesar reads this letter, he might be further warned, but if not, the fate of Caesar’s life will be in the favor of the conspirators who intend to kill him.
Scene IV
1. Portia is a loyal wife to Brutus, and truly loves him. She is concerned because of his strange behavior over the days preceding the ides of March. She sends Lucius to check on Brutus at the Senate House, and tries to find out from the soothsayer what is going on. She probably has an idea of what is going on between Caesar and Brutus, and her feelings are further confirmed after talking to the soothsayer.
Scene 1
1)What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Answer:
Brutus had no personal reason for killing Caesar. He said that he had the best interest of the people of Rome in mind. It was a group of people or a faction that wanted to kill Caesar.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Answer:
It doesn't change my views of Brutus because he's scared that the power of being king will change Caesar and their friendship.
3). Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Answer;
Brutus doesn't want to take the oath because he thought that their cause would be enough to bond them together.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Answer: She notices that Brutus is acting weird and asked him about it. She told him that she was his wife and he shouldn't keep secrets from her.
scene 2 .
1) How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
Answer;
the weather is very bad. They are having lots of storms which signify the worry of the people that are near Caesar, and bad things are approaching.
2) Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
Answer: Brutus shows up to take him to the capital and says that she misinterpreted the dream and it was actually a good omen.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Answer:
Brutus is sad because Caesar believes he is his friend and brutus is going to betray him.
Scene 3 -
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
Answer:
It shows foreshadowing because it said that brutus doesn't love him. it also said to beware of the people around you if you are not immortal.
Scene 4 -
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4
Answer;
She is acting very weird. she sends Lucius to the state building. she said that she had the mind of a man and strength of a woman. she is very frantic. She is worried about Caesar. she thinks that something will happen to him.
Aaron Hieneman 5th period
Act II, Scene I
1.) What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Answer: In Brutus' soliloquy he says that he has no personal reason for wanting to kill Caeser that he is going to kill him for the good of Rome.
2.) Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Answer: In my opion Brutus is a good person but he is his thoughts of murdering Caeser are justified, but his murder is not for the good of Rome, therefore it is not right.
3.) Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Answer: he denies taking the oath because he believes that there cause to kill Caeser is strong enough to bind them together. So they decided upon not taking the oath.
4.) How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Answer: She conforts him in the best way possible, she had been noticeing that Brutus had been acting strange lately, she conforts Brutus in telling him that he can trust her with his secrets because she is his wife.
Act II, Scene II
1.) How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
Answer: the Weather is reflecting that there is something bad approaching because of the thunderstorms that are approaching are usally not a very good sign.
2.) Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
Answer: he is convinced by Decius to go out into rome, also he is convinced that the gods are testing him, he thinks that they are wanting to see if he is a man or not.
3.) Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Answer: Brutus is upset because he know that Caeser believes, that Brutus is his best friend and he would never betray him and he loves him. He also knows that he is going o be betrayed by the only people that he could truely trust.
Act II, Scene III
1.) How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
Answer: The letter is foreshadowing because in the letter it tells caeser that brutus does not love him as friend. It also tells Caeser to beware to go out into the public unless he is immortal and so its showing alot of foreshadowing.
Act II, Scene IV
1.) Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4.
Answer: She is showing love for her husband by telling Lucuis to go and find Caeser at the senate. He needs to be told about the letter and how they are plannig to kill him. Also she asks for Lucius to watch over Caeser and make sure that no one would hurt. Shes trying to protect her husband in best way possible they know theirs going to be someone trying to kill Caeser and shes going to try and stop them.
Samantha Furst
Scene 1 -
1. What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Answer: Brutus’ loved Caesar for who he was. Brutus’ had nothing against Caesar personally. His motives for killing Caesar were never revengeful. He was simply doing this for the good of the people, for the good of Rome.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Answer: Yes. This changes the way I view Brutus. In the beginning Brutus never thought of Caesar the way Cassius did. He didn’t plan to kill him, or even feel hatred toward his power like Cassius did. Then when Cassius talks to Brutus, Brutus agrees to the plan. It makes it seem that Brutus was only following along with everyone else and had no true plan to kill Caesar. In his soliloquy all his motives seem to turn inward and completely change. Now he did have a reason, now he wanted Caesar to die. Now he wanted the best for the Roman people, but what about before? He fell into persuasion and started believing in Cassius’ plan. He was not justified. He never even tried to talk to Caesar and mention how he feared Caesar would change. He just decided to go ahead and kill him.
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Answer: Because Brutus believed that an oath would be pointless. If the men were not already motivated enough to go through with it, an oath would do nothing, and neither would they.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Answer: She realizes Brutus has been acting strange and confronts him. He tells her over and over it’s nothing but she knows better. She tells him she deserves to know the truth, being his wife, and she will not tell his secrets.
Scene 2 -
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
Answer: Bad weather is a sign that something bad is going on, or will happen. The bad weather in scene 2 reflects the bad things that are coming up in the story.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
Answer: He goes out eve know his wife’s dream because Decius convinces Caesar that the dream was misinterpreted, and that the dream really meant that he would provide Rome with sustaining blood, and the best men would do anything to get some token of approval from his holy body. Caesar believed this, Decius tricked him.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Answer: Brutus feels bad because him and Caesar were truly great friends. Now he is going to destroy him and Caesar has no idea of his plans. Even know Brutus believed Caesar should die for the good of Rome's people, he still felt bad for plotting to kill him.
Scene 3 -
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
Answer: Artemidorius’ letter warns Caesar not trust these certain men, which are actually the men plotting to kill him. This letter foreshadows the death Caesar will have by the men Artemidorus warned him about. Artemidorus try’s to protect Caesar, which is the role of fate in this letter.
Scene 4 -
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4.
Answer: Portia is aware of some things that are about to and are happening. She tells her servant Lucuis to go to the capitol and return to her once he’d been there. She wants him to find out what is going on and what has happened so far. She also talks to a soothsayer to find out what is going on.
1. Brutus' soliloquy shows us that he truly wishes that he didn't have to kill Caesar. But he is convinced that there is no other option. He loves Rome so much that he is willing to kill to protect it. He has convinced himself (with the help of Cassius) that Caesar will bring about the downfall of Rome and he is the only one that can stop it.
2. Brutus' decisions as well as his soliloquy have not changed my opinion of him. My first impression was that he was a very gentle, self-sacrificing person. But also that he was very easily manipulated person. In my opinion, all this is still true. He doesn't want to kill, but believes he must for the good of everything. He was manipulated into doing all this by a very bad person. All of these things still correspond with my first impression of Brutus.
3. Brutus doesn't want to pledge an oath to his co-conspirators because he believes that oaths are evil things and betrayals of trust.
4. Potia reacts to Brutus' strange behavior by being concerned for her husband. She wants to know what is troubling him so she can help.
1. The weather gets worse and stranger to reflect the strange and terrible things that are happening and will happen.
2. Ceaser goes to the capitol despite his wife's warning because Decius tells him that Calpunia's dream was not a warning, but as an omen of good things that will happen. Decius tells him that the people will think Ceaser is a coward if he doesn't go out. That is the las thing Ceaser wants is to damage his reputation.
3. He wishes that he didn't have to kill Ceaser, but instead that they could be friends.
1. Artemidorus' letter foreshadow because it tells Caesar almost the entire plan for his assassination. However, it shows the role of fate, because it gives off the air that Caesars death is inevitable.
1. In Act Two, Scene Three, Portia is very nervous. She sends Lucius to the Capitol building to see if her husband has completed his plan. She doesn't know what to do. The soothsayer comes along to talk to her, and gives her even more to worry about. She is feeling weak with all the stress, so sends Lucius on his way, then goes inside to lay down to wait.
Act II Questions
2nd Period
Scene 1:
1.) Brutus' soliloquy shows that he is only going to kill Caesar for the good of all Rome. Not because of any personal reasons against him.
2.) Yes, it changed the way I veiwed Brutus. At first I thought he was just a horrible person who wanted to kill Caeasar just because he didn't like him. Now, however, I see he is just doing the wrong things for the right reasons, and he is a better person than i originally gave him credit for.
3.) He didn't want to take an oath because he thought that they should all do what they were going to do because they wanted to, not because they were bound by an oath they had made.
4.) She confronts him about it, stating that she thinks he has a problem that he isn't telling her about, even though he should tell her because she is his wife.
Scene 2:
1.) The weather is stormy and such. Which signifies all of the mixed feeling the people in Rome have over Caesar.
2.) He still goes out because Decius tells Caesar that Calpurnia misinterpreted her dream, and that it was really a good omen instead of a bad.
3.) He is sad because he knows that he is going to betray Caesar, and Caesar thinks that he can deeply trust Brutus.
Scene 3:
1.) It's foreshadowing because the letter basically tells Caesar of his future assassination. However, the letter plays it off as if the Gods will handle the situation as it should be, which shows how fate works into the whole scheme.
Scene 4:
1.) In scene four, Portia shows that she is very concerned about her husband. Especially for what he is planning on doing. She is also very different from the other women, she says that she has the mind of a man, but the strength of a woman.
Scene 1 -
1. I think the soliloquy shows that Brutis didn't really want to kill Caesar but on does it because he thinks its best for Rome.
2. No, the soliloquy does not change my opinion of Brutis but rather solidify my first impression, which is that of him as a noble man who is a true patriot for his country. this just shows the extremes he is willing to go to for Rome. Even so I don't think that his reasons are justified because he seems to have the "Spartan" mentality of the physically weak being worthless, and he's being easily persuaded.
3.He does not feel the need to take an oath because he thinks their trustworthy cause is enough to bond them.
4.When Portia sees brutis acting strange she is worried. then she upset because he is keeping a secret from her, his wife.
Scene 2 -
1.The bad weather is a precursor for what is about to happen in the play.
2.Easer goes out dispite his wife's wishes because Decius tells him that her dream was a good omen and that if he does not the people will think he is a coward.
3.He is sad because he knows Caesar trusts him , and he is about to kill Caesar.
Scene 3 -
1. The letter tells of people betraying him and foreshadows that he is in grave danger.
Scene 4 -
1. Portia is becoming very curious. She does not know how but she knows that they intend to harm Ceasar, so she sends someone to "spy" on him and then questions the soothsayer.Shes catching on and this may turn out rather interesting.
Scene 1
1) He states that he has nothing personal against him, but he feels as if Caesar is not the best person to rule the people. He also believes that once Caesar is crowned, he might change, so he feels it'd be best to just get rid of him.
2) Yes this does change they way I feel about Brutus. Even though he cares about the people and city of Rome's well being, it isnt motive enought to kill someone over it. No matter the cause, it isnt good enough reason for him to kill Caesar.
3) Brutus does not take the oath because he says that there motive was good enough and that they did not need an oath to prove their cause.
4) She is very curious as to why he is acting so strangely, and wants to know his reasoning behind his strange ways. She is also very angered at the fact that she isn't allowed to know everything that goes on in her husband's life.
Scene 2
1) The weather is a sign of bad things that are about to happen. Like the bad that a storm can bring, the story only unravels more bad things.
2) He is told by another person that his wife's dream was misread, and thats not what was going to happen. Caesar also believes that whatever happens will happens at the God's will so he might as well do what was planned.
3) He is upset because Caesar tells him that he is a good friend and that he trusts him; and then Brutus realizes what he is planning on doing his bad, especially to someone who feels this way about him.
Scene 3
1) His letter is foreshadowing the fact that people around him, also known as traitors, are planning to kill him. The letter warns that if it is not read, that Caesar's future will be in the hands of the fates of his traitors.
Scene 4
1) Portia is acting very aggrevated when speaking to Lucius. She is obviously hiding something, and states that because she has a man's mind and a woman's strength, it is harder for her to keep her secrets safe. She also seems very interested in Caesar's health, and interested in the people that he is close to, which leads one to think she might be planning on having something to do with what Brutus is planning. She also seems very paranoid, because she makes a big deal out of hearing a noise.
Scene 1 -
1. In his sililoquy, Brutus tells us that he must kill Brutus because he will be crowned king and become dangerous. He says, "And therefore think him as a serpent's egg— / Which, hatched, would as his kind grow mischievous—" meaning he would corrupt with all the power. So now they must kill him before that happens.
2. I view Brutus a little differently now. Before, I thought he was very mischievous, manipulative, and selfish. Now, I see him as a little less selfish because this shows he is not trying to overrule Caesar for his power, he is simply trying to protect his fellow Romans.
3. Brutus thinks that oaths are for weak people. He tells Cassius, "Unto bad causes swear / Such creatures as men doubt." Their cause for their actions should be strong enough to keep them going.
4. Portia tells Brutus that she deserves to know what was going on and who was at their house that night. They were married, and therefore, now one person sharing all their thoughts and worries. She wanted him to tell her what the problem was and what they were up to.
Scene 2 -
1. The weather in this scene, which is thunder and lightening, shows is that terrible things are going to happen.
2. Caesar ignores his wife's dream and goes out because Decius thinks the dream was lucky. He also does not want Decius or the senate to talk about him and think he is a coward.
3. Brutus is sad because he knows that he is going to kill him soon so he has to pretend to be his friend for now.
Scene 3 -
1. Artemidorius' letter is very foreshadowing. It basically says "you're probably going to die, and here's who is going to cause it." We know that something is going to happen very soon. The letter is also showing us the role of fate in the story. In the letter, Artemidorius says, "If thou read this, O Caesar, thou mayst live. / If not, the Fates with traitors do contrive." He is saying whatever happens, happens, and he can not control it.
Scene 4 -
1. In scene 4, Portia is frantically trying to check on her husband. She knows something is going on, so she is worried. She tries to send Lucius to the senate house to see if Caesar is still ok. Then Portia speaks with the soothsayer asking if he knows anything about any plots against Caesar and askes him to go make sure he is fine.
Act 2, Scene 1:
1. Brutus' soliloquy shows that he has no personal reason to strike out at Caesar beside for the best interest of the people and Rome. Brutus says that if he is crowned then they will be giving him the power to do damage.
2. This does change my opinion and view of Brutus some. Before I read this I thought that Brutus was just joining the crowd and was doing what everyone else wanted. But now I see that he actually has thought about it and gave reason to why he thinks that Caesar shouldn't be in power. But at the same time I believe that Cassius has told him that Caesar is not the best leader for Rome and Brutus really believes him. He's really not that smart about it.
3. He doesn't want to take an oath because he believes that he will do the right thing. Kind of like whatever happens, happens.
4. Portia knew something was up with the way that Brutus was acting. When she comfronted him about it. She said she had the right to know since she was his wife and was part of his life.
Act 2, Scene 2:
1. The weather pretty much explains itself. There is storms going on which is symbolic of all the turmoil and bad things about to happen In Rome.
2. He still goes out because Decius interprets his wife's dream differently. Also Caesar thinks that this Is a test from the gods.
3. He is sad because Caesar trusts Brutus and Brutus is going to go beyond that trust and kill his friend. Also he is doing this behind his back. Caesar knows nothing about his plan.
Act 2, Scene 3:
1. It is forshadowing because Artemidorius' letter includes things such as about how Brutus didn’t love him and all the things that are about to unfold later on in the play.
Act 2, Scene 4:
1. Portia starts to wonder about what Brutus is up to. She tells the servant to go check on him and tell him that she is happy. She can sense that something is not right. She knew that he was keeping something from her.
Act 2, Scene 1
1. Brutus' soliloquy in Scene 1 states that he is going to kill Caesar for the good of everyone in Rome, and not because he has anything against Caesar. He is afraid Caesar will become too thoughtless once he gets all that power.
2. Brutus' motives show a lot about his personality. He is very noble and caring, and puts the needs of others before himself. He puts the well being of the people before everything, including himself. I do think that Brutus' motives are justified.
3. Brutus doesn't want to take an oath with the others because he feels that only weak men need oaths. He says that if the pain of the Roman people is not enough to get them to stay on track, then there is no need to even plan what they're doing. In his opinion, oaths are only there to guide the weak and hold people to false truths.
4. Portia reacts to Brutus' strange behavior in a very exaggerated way. She asks Brutus what has been bothering him, stating that his troubles should also be hers, or there would be no point in their marriage. At one point she even kneels in front of him and begins to beg that he tell her what is wrong.
Act 2, Scene 2
1. The weather going on in the background of the play symbolizes what is about to happen to Caesar, and provides an ominous outlook for the day's events.
2. Caesar continues to go ahead to the senate house because Decius tells him that Calphurnia's dream has been misinterpreted. In her dream a statue of Caesar begins to spout fountains of blood and Romans bathe in it. Decius says that means that through Caesar all Romans will prosper.
3. Brutus is sad during his aside at the end of the scene because Caesar says "... and we, like friends, shall drink..." Brutus says that he can see that Caesar already sees himself above them, because he said "like" friends, and not just friends.
Act 2, Scene 3
1. Artemidordius' letter shows foreshadowing because he is talking about what is about to happen to Caesar. It also shows it because he mentions that if Caesar doesn't read it, he'll be beyond hope. That pretty much means he wont read it.
Act 2, Scene 4
1. Portia's actions during Scene 4 show just how worried she is for Brutus, and how much she cares as to whether or not Brutus is okay. She acts very distressed, and even forgets to tell the boy she sends to check on Brutus what to do a few times. Her actions show that Brutus is rarely ever in a bad mood, or she wouldn't be so concerned.
Scene 1 -
1. What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Brutus knows without reason that Cesar will be crowned king, but he is still uneasy on whether Caesar will let the power become to addictive. Brutus tries to reason saying he has never seen Caesar with a power struggle in the past, buts is afraid that with Caesar rising to great powerful heights, he will scorn those who are lower in status. Brutus uses the comparison of Caesar to the egg of a serpent saying “which, hatched, would as his kind grow mischievous”; because of this he decides to “kill him in the shell”.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
No this does not change the way I see Brutus. Brutus is strong minded and aware of what can happen, when power is put into a situation. Not only is Brutus looking after himself, his is looking the “low in status people”, trying to shield them from what Caesar could become.
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Brutus believes that there is no need for an oath, because the cause should be strong and important enough to keep them bound together.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Portia reacts as any normal wife would, seeing as her husband seemed to have uneasy thoughts. She asks him why he refuses to tell her his concerns, promising that once told about his problems she would keep it secret.
Scene 2 -
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
The horrible unpredictable weather shows itself as omens during the play; Warning of the horrible things yet to come, to Caesar.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
Caesar continues to go out despite his wife’s dream because he feels that nothing can change the plans of the gods. He thinks that signs must apply to the world in general and not to him personally. Caesar does not fear death, because it must come eventually to all.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Brutus is sad during his aside, because Caesar has put his trust into Brutus, not expecting him to help plan out his death. Brutus wishes they could still be friends, but knows he must go through with the plan.
Scene 3 -
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
Artemidorius’ letter represents both foreshadowing and the role fate is playing in the work. The letter is warning Caesar to be wary of Brutus, and the other Conspirators; this is foreshadowing the men who will be responsible for Caesars death. Artemidorius said, “I pray that the mighty gods defend you!”, which is where fate comes into play.
Scene 4 -
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4.
Portia seems very worried what will come of her husband. With all her raging thoughts she sends Brutus’s servants to the Senate to see how things are going and report back to her. When the soothsayer enters she turns to him asking if Caesar has gone to the capitol yet. He replies that he knows that Caesar has not gone yet.
Scene 1 -
1. What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Answer - Brutus' soliloquy informs us that he feels great remorse for the task at hand. He truly doesn't want to kill Caesar, yet his patriotism fuels him to do so. He feels as if he is doing the right thing for Rome by killing Caesar, as if he is making a sacrifice for the city he loves.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Answer - The way I view Brutus does not change. I first thought of him as an honorable, respectable and patriotic man who stands up for what he believes in and acts for what he believes to be the best for society. He seem like a man who rises to action when he feels it is required. Though Brutus feels he is right and doing an honorable thing, I do not believe his motives are justified. Resulting to bloodshed is not necessary by any means.
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Answer - Brutus does not want to make an oath with the conspirators because he is confident that their cause is a just and noble one.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Answer - Portia reacts to Brutus' strange behavior with at first curiosity as to why he is acting so queerly. When he tells her she cannot know, she pleads and begs, worried with her husband's strange behavior. She also feels untrustworthy, as if Brutus cannot confide in her, his own wife.
Scene 2 -
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
Answer - The weather is relative to the events building up in the story. The bad weather is developing and becoming a symbol for tragic events to follow.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
Answer - Caesar chooses to go out despite his wife's desperate warnings because Decius convinces that Calphurnia's dream interpretation was completely wrong. Decius tells Caesar that the dream is one of good luck, fortune, and if he does not go out, he will be thought of as a coward.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Answer - Brutus is sad because he is about to betray Caesar and lead him to his death. Caesar loves and trusts Brutus, and is completely oblivious to the events ahead of him, which only adds to Brutus' sorrow.
Scene 3 -
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
Answer - The letter shows foreshadowing by convincing one to believe that maybe Caesar will discover the plot of the conspirators before it's too late. It also shows the role of fate by maybe causing one to think that if the letter does in fact reach Caesar, he can do something about the attempt on his life, as if his fate relies on receiving that letter.
Scene 4 -
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4.
Answer - She is very curios and worried. She cannot handle the suspense that her husband could be struck down in the street at any moment. In her paranoia, she even sends a someone to check on her husband and take note of the men close to him. This lets the reader know she is aware of an attack, and may be able to interfere.
Act 2 questions 5th period
Scene 1
1. What are Brutus' motives for killing Caesar?
Its as simple as fear. According to Brutus, he is like a snake in an egg and must be destroyed before he can hatch.
2. Does this change the way you look at Brutus? Describe him and elaborate on your views about his motives for killing Caesar, is he justified?
No, I expect brutus to act this way. He is a gentle soul but seems to be easily manipulated. When he questions the morality when Cassius is trying to get him to do something cruel, he convinces himself its "ok" to do what he is asked.
His motives are shaky at best. Brutus is relying on a chance that something bad might happen if Caesar becomes king. Is this situation, they are killing someone who is innocent of crimes he is being killed for. This means of dealing judgment is definitely not justified.
3. Why does Brutus refrain from making a pact with the other people involved in the conspiracy?
Brutus feels that is if this is a just cause worthy to put their lives on the line for, just the fact that they are all committed and trust-worthy should be enough. He thinks they are above oaths and pacts.
4.What does Portia do about Brutus's odd behavior?
Portia is worried about Brutus. She has noticed and been affected by his strange behavior and wants to know whats going on with her husband.
Scene 2
1.what is the weather saying about the play.
That bad things a are unfolding. Its a sign the worst is yet to come.
2.Why does Caesar go despite his wife's "warning"?
Decius tells Caesar that his wife interpreted his dream incorrectly. That it was a good omen and not something to fear.
3.Why is Brutus upset near the end of the scene?
Caesar says, "Good friends, go in and have some wine with me. And we'll leave together, like friends." Brutus feels that Caesar no longer sees him as a true friend.
Scene 3
1.How is the letter of Artemidorius both foreshadowing and the role fate is playing?
It's foreshadowing in the since that all of these people will, in fact, eventually kill Caesar. Fate is put into the mix by when Artemidorius says, "If you read this, Caesar, you might live. If not, the Fates are on the side of the traitors." He means that if fate should have it, Caesar will get the letter, if not then he is a grave situation.
scene 4
1. write a paragraph about the actions of Portia in this scene.
She is quite panic stricken. As she runs around its easy to tell by the choice of words that she is beside herself. The anxiety must be hard to bear, she was rambling on to Lucius, "Boy, I beg you to run to the senate house. Don't stay to answer me—get going. Why are you still standing there?" In short, her mind was panicked and racing while she was doing her best to save Caesar.
Ashley Barlow
-Act 2- Scene 1
1. Brutus soliloquy shows us that his motives for killing Ceasar aren’t out of anger. He killing Ceasar for what he thinks is for the good of Rome.
2. Yes, it does change the way I feel about Brutus. Brutus is a noble Roman man who is easily persuaded. In his mind he thinks he is killing Ceasar for the good of Rome but in reality he’s just been manipulated into thinking he’s doing what’s right by Cassius. Brutus isn’t Justified for killing Ceasar.
3. I think he don’t take an oath or sake hands because he might change his mind about killing Ceasar.
4. Portia freaks out. She knows that there’s something bothering Brutus but she really has no idea he’s going to kill ceasar. She thinks he might have a cold.
Scene 2
1. The storm added mood and represents Ceasars attitude about going out. Also it represents what bad things are to come.
2. Ceasar goes anyway because Brutus comes over and interprets the dream differently and talks him into going.
3. He’s sad because he feels bad for killing Ceasar. Ceasar is his friend and he’s going to stab him in the back.
Scene 3
1. Artemidorius letter foreshadows Ceasars death. By the author and the role of fate. The letter say to watch out for the people who are close to him because there trying to kill him.
Scene 4
1. Portia wants to keep her husbands secret but she also wants to know what’s going on at the Senate. She sent Lucius to go to the Senate to “ see it Brutus is feeling well” but she there going to be trouble there and she wants to know what’s going on.
Act II, Scene ii
1. What does Brutus’ soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Answer: Brutus wants to kill Caesar for the good of Rome, rather that the good of himself. Cassius wants to kill Caesar for his own good.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Answer: Yes, this makes him seem much for of a “good guy” in the play. He is concerned of the wellbeing of Rome. He is not justified, though looking out for Rome; it is not his position to take such dramatic action
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Answer: He says you would only give an oath to someone you don’t trust. He wants their trust without an oath.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus’ strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Answer: She is concerned and tries to figure out what is troubling him.
Act II, Scene ii
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
Answer: It is storming, which sets an eerie mood. A murder is about to take place, so the weather goes good with these events.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife’s dream?
Answer: He is afraid of being made fun of, and seeming weak. He doesn’t want to empower Caesar, either
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Answer: He is sad because he has to kill Caesar for the good of Rome. He actually likes Caesar, and this is why he is upset
Act II, Scene iii
1. How does Artemidorious’ letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing?
Answer: It tells who will kill Caesar. It says due to the will of the gods, Caesar’s fate depends on whether he reads the letter or not.
Act II, Scene iv
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia’s actions in Scene 4.
She is finding out what is going on. She doesn’t know for sure yet. Portia is doing all she can to find out more. She doesn’t want Caesar to be harmed and is very worried.
Act 2, Scene I
1. What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Answer- Brutus' soliloquy shows that Brutus wants to kil Caesar for the good of Rome.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Answer- No this does'nt change the way I view Brutus. But it shows that he is a very weakperson by letting other people decide what he does and does'nt do. Cassius is the one that talked him into killing Caesar.
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Answer- Brutus does'nt want take the oath because he says that their cause would be strong enough to bind them together.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Answer- She confronted Brutus about keeping a secret from her and she told him that his secrets were safe with her.
Act 2, Scene III
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
Answer- The storm represents all of the different feelings about Caesar in Rome.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
Answer- He is afraid it will make him look wea and he might be made fun of.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Answer- Brutus is sad because in the process of killing Caesar, which he has to do for the good of Rome, he is killing someone that he likes.
Act 2, Scene III
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
Answer- The letter tells who will kill Caesar. It also says that Caesar's fate depends on whether or not he read the letter.
Act 2, Scene IV
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4.
Answer- Portia is becoming very curious she does'nt know how but she does know that someone wants to harm Caesar. So she sends someone to spy on him after this she talks to the soothsayer.
CONTINUED FROM BEFORE
Act 2 Scene 4:
1. Portia is being a traditional wife, and she is worried about Caesar, as any good wife would be. She is paranoid that something bad is going to happen to Caesar, so she tried to get Lucius to do some espionage work in a sense, but her thoughts do not come out clearly due to her frantic mind. And when she confronts the soothsayer, it only adds to her worries, and she asks Lucius to check on Caesar and tell him that she is doing fine, and for Lucius to return and report what Caesar said.
Scene 1
1. It shows that he doesn't want to kill Caesar, but he thinks that it's the best for Rome, and the only way that Caesar won't take advantage of his power. Brutus just wants what's in the best interest of the people, and he believes that if Caesar were crowned, then they would be giving Caesar power to damage Rome.
2. No, this does not change my view of Brutus. Brutus says in his soliloquy that he has never seen Caesar let his emotions get better of his reason. Brutus believes that Caesar would not take advantage of his power, but Cassius had now made Brutus think that if other ambitious young men will damage the country, Caesar will do the same. Brutus only wants whats best for Rome, and will do anything for it. He has not thought of his friend Caesar, or the consequences of killing him. I think that he thinks his reasons are justified, but I believe the opposite. Before impulsively joining Cassius' side, and plotting against Caesar, I think Brutus should think more thoroughly.
3. Brutus does not want to take oath with the other conspirators, because he believes that if they are all in, and they think that this is the absolute best for Rome, they should not have to take oath. The knowing that they are bettering Rome should be motivation enough. He thinks that only cowards take oaths, and if anyone would betray them anyway, they would not be a noble Roman.
4. From Brutus strange behavior, Portia drills Brutus for answers, kneeling and saying that she is Brutus' wife, and that he shouldn't keep secrets. Portia then explains that she is stronger than other women becuase of her bloodlines, and that she can handle secrets. She then talks Brutus into telling her.
Scene 2
1.The weather reflects what is going on in the play because the weather is stormy, which consists of thunder and lightning, and Calphurnia has just seen bad omens, knowing that something bad is going to happen. The weather reflects because the stormy weather is bad and brings worse things, as does the future.
2. Caesar goes out despite Calphurnia's dream, because Decius interprets her dreams differently, convincing him to go. Decius tells him that if he doesn't go, people will make fun, becuse he didin't come just because of his wife's dream. He also tells him that they'll think he's afraid, and a coward if he doesn't go. This convinces Caesar, in spite of the bad dreams Calphurnia had.
3. Brutus is sad towards the end of the scene because Caesar includes Brutus as his friend. Although Brutus used to be good friends with Caesar, he is now planning to kill Caesar, and knows differently.
Scene 3
1. Artemidorious’ letter was foreshadowing because he is naming off all the people that are the conspirators, and that are plotting to kill Caesar. He is warning Caesar that these few individuals are not good, and that troubled times are ahead. Following the reading of the letter, Artemidorus then says that if Caesar does read the letter, that Caesar wll be forewarned and might live, if not though, fate is on the traitor's side.
Scene 4
1. Portia was stressed during this time. She gives orders to Lucius, without even explaining, while Lucius just stands there, confused. She was wanting Lucious to go investigate at the senate house, wondering what is happening, because she is worrying about Brutus and Caesar. She then talks to the soothsayer about Caesar, asking and trying to figure out if Cassius' plan to kill Caesar is going to be carried out.
Scene 1
1)What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Answer:
Brutus had no personal reason for killing Caesar. He said that he had the best interest of the people of Rome in mind. It was a group of people or a faction that wanted to kill Caesar.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Answer:
It doesn't change my views of Brutus because he's scared that the power of being king will change Caesar and their friendship.
3). Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Answer;
Brutus doesn't want to take the oath because he thought that their cause would be enough to bond them together.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Answer: She notices that Brutus is acting weird and asked him about it. She told him that she was his wife and he shouldn't keep secrets from her.
scene 2 .
1) How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
Answer;
the weather is very bad. They are having lots of storms which signify the worry of the people that are near Caesar, and bad things are approaching.
2) Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
Answer: Brutus shows up to take him to the capital and says that she misinterpreted the dream and it was actually a good omen.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Answer:
Brutus is sad because Caesar believes he is his friend and brutus is going to betray him
Scene 3 -
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
Answer:
It shows foreshadowing because it said that brutus doesn't love him. it also said to beware of the people around you if you are not immortal.
Scene 4 -
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4
Answer;
She is acting very weird. she sends Lucius to the state building. she said that she had the mind of a man and strength of a woman. she is very frantic. She is worried about Caesar. she thinks that something will happen to him
Act II Scene I
1. What does Brutus' soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
In his soliloquy, Brutus tells us that he must kill Brutus because he will be crowned king and become dangerous so now they must kill him before he ruins Rome.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Yes this does change the way I feel about Brutus. I believe it is justified. Sometimes rulers have to do what’s right for the kingdom and not just what’s right for one person.
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Brutus doesn't want to pledge an oath to the other conspirators because he thinks that oaths are evil and betray trust.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus' strange behavior at the end of the scene?
She confronts him. He says it’s nothing but she knows there’s something wrong with him.
Act II Scene II
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
The weather is very bad almost supernatural it seems. Caesar’s friends and family worry that the weather is symbolic to what will happen to him.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife's dream?
Decius convinces Caesar that his wife misinterpreted the dream. Decius tells Caesar it is actually a good omen. Caesar believed him.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Because he and Caesar were really good friends and now he is going to kill Caesar.
Act II Scene III
1. How does Artemidorius' letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing in the work?
The letter represents foreshadowing because he tells Caesar to beware al of those around if he is not immortal. Artemidorius is basically telling Caesar that if he can be killed, he will be killed.
Act II Scene IIII
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia's actions in Scene 4.
Portia is doing everything she can to make her husband aware. She tells Lucius to go to the senate to tell Caesar about the letter. She has the mind of a man but the body of a woman. She wants to save her husband but only men could save other men.
Act2, scene 1
1.) Brutus' solilque shows that he is only doing this for the good of Rome.
2.)yes my view has changed because I saw him as a follower, doing what he was told. but now I see him as a loyal follower to Pompey and i see him as gullible, and easy to mislead.
3.) Brutus denies taking an oath because he thinks thee cause is strong enough to bind them together.
4.) Portia saw that he was acting strangely so se questioned him about it. She said she was his wife and wold keep his secrets.
Act2, scene 2
1.)The storm shows the jumbling feelings of Rome about Caesar.
2.) Because decius convinces him that Calphurnia's ddream was a good omen instead of a warning.
3.)because he is upset because he is going to betray Caesar.
Act2, scene 3
1.)forshodows brutus' killing Caesar and fate is acting in brus' favor.
Act2, scene 4
1.) she acts as if she knows brutus s going to kill Caesar. She is worried an her worry becomes greater when the soothsayer enters the scene.
Questions continued 2nd period
2.) No, it doesn't change the way that i view Brutus. He is a good person, who cares for the people of Rome. He only wants the best for them.
3.) When Brutus was talking to Cassius about the oath, Brutus said, "If the sad faces of our fellow men, that suffering of our own souls, and the corruption of the present time aren't enough to motive us." And what oath do we need other than that we need honest men have told each other than that we need honest men have told each other that this will happen or we will die trying? so really they have no need for an oath.
4.) She was upset,and was asking questions about what was wrong with him. She thought that since she was his wife, that he should keep no secrets from her. Porti a said "Tell me your counsels: i will not disclose 'em."
Scene 2
1.) During the play it stormed very badly. Caesar and his wife had slept badly because of the storm, just like all of the others in Rome. The weather is bad, and so is the fight between Caesar and Brutus. It's like a competion between them, for which one is bigger and better, just like thunder and lighting.
2.) Calpurnia's dream was a vision fair, and fortunate. It was a statue of Caesar spouting blood in many pipes, in which many smiling Romans bathed in. So because of this dream Calpurnia thinks that it is best for Caesar to stay home for a while. Decius has to get him out of the house, so to get him out he must give Caesar a new interpetation of Calpurnia's dream. The reason why Decius is doing this, is because he told the others that he could say anything and flatter Caesar into to believing anything.
3.) Brutus said, "That every like is not the same, O Caesar, The heart of Brutus yearns to think upon." When he talks about this he is saying, even though Caesar and him act like friends, doesn't mean that they really are. Just to of them like that, makes his heart grieve.
Scene 3
1.) Artemidorus, was a supporter of Caesar, and was also the person who wrote a letter to him (Caesar). The reason that he had wrote the letter, was to warn Caesar to beware of Brutus, and his men. The letter is representing both the author, and the role playing the work by foreshadowing, because it is kind of giving you an idea of what might be happening later on as the future comes.
Scene 4
1.) Portia's actions, were starting to become worse. She was feeling anxious about the conspiracy, and upset with herself witht he way she acted. Later on in the scene she sends Lucius, a servant to the capitol and see what is going on. While the servant is gone, she meets up with the soothsayer, who keeps predicting danger for Caesar, and making her more anxious than she had been before.
Act II Questions
Scene I
1. It shows that he does not want to kill Caesar just out of anger but only for the good his country, Rome.
2. Yes, this does change the way I view Brutus, because before I just thought he was out to kill Caesar because he was going along with everyone else and he had no real reason. But after hearing Brutus' reasons and thoughts on it, I discovered that Brutus only wants to kill him for the good. He is that loyal to his country and I decided that, yes he is justified.
3. He doesn't want to take the oath because he feels that if they arent doing this just for the good of Rome they shouldnt be doing it at all.
4. Portia thinks that something is wrong with Brutus, her husband, right off the bat. She is curious to know exactly what is going on and she is worried that Brutus' strange behavior could lead to bad things.
Scene II
1.The weather in Rome right now is rainy, and stormy, therefore it is mostly gloomy out. The killing of Caesar that they are planning is gloomy as well, because obviously, death is not such a pleasant thing.
2.Caesar goes out despite his wifes dream because Decius reinterprets her dream, into something that is positive and doesnt lead to any harm. Caesar is persuaded, so he goes out no matter his wifes thought.
3. Brutus is sad because he knows that what he is about to do to Caesar is nothing but betrayal.
Scene III
1. The letter shows foreshadowing because it is telling Caesar to watch his back because who he thought were his friends, really arent, because they are out to get him. It also shows the role fate because it is pretty much telling Caesar that if he isnt careful he could die.
Scene 4
1. Portia, Caesars wife, is very worried about Caesar because she has a gut feeling that all is not well. She sends Lucius to go check out everything and see exactly what is going on. She is only doing this to ensure that he husband will be okay.
Scene 1
1)Brutus' soliloquy shows us that he only want's to help rome by killing caesar.
2)no it doesnt change my view of him because he thought killing caesar was the best thing for rome.
3) He didnt take the oath because he wasnt sure about killing caesar.
4)Portia begged brutus to tell her what bothered him so much.
Scene 2
1)The weather was, thundering and lighting. It sounds like something bad is going to happen soon.
2)He goes out because Decius convinces him to go into town.
3)Brutus is sad because he think's caesar beleieves that brutus is his friend and he's just pretneding to be.
Scene 3
1)Artemidorius' letter is foreshadowing and it convices us that caesar is definetly going to be murdered.
Scene 4
1)Portia's actions in scene 4 was, as if she was onto what brutus was planning, to kill caesar.
act 2
scene 1
1.) It show that he likes caesar and considers him a friend. Brutus doesn't have a personal problem with caesar, he just wants whats best for rome. He uses the excuse that they just want to stop the problem before it starts. He also compares caesar to a serpants egg that they have to squash before he becomes dangerous.
2.)This does change the way i view Brutus. I thought Brutus had more integrity than that. HE seemed like the type to stick to his beliefs and not be swayed by the opinions of others. He was againest killing caesar but the more he talked to the rebellious people like cassius, the more he agreed to it until he became like their leader. He is a nobal person and people are willing to follow him into anything. But by killing caesar he would just besmerch his title as a dignified person. I used to think Brutus would pick the right path but his solilquy changed mmy mind.
3.)He thinks that an oath means that one of the conspirators is having second thoughts about killing caesar, and that means one of them is too weak to follow through with their plans. So it seems to me that Brutus takes oaths as a sign of weakness.
4.)She realizes that something is wrong with Brutus and feels that as his wife she has the right to know whats wrong with him.
scene 2
1.)THe weather is chaotic and so are the actions the conspirators are planning. The thunder and lightning are dark and threatening and they enhance the mood set by the plotting and sceming.
2.) HE says that the omens apply to everyone, and that just because they're there, it doesn't mean that they were intended for him. He also says that the omens will vanish once he goes out because he is mighty caesar.
3.)He is sad because caesar says "like" friends. Caesar doesn't consider them real friends and only wants it to appear like they are. However Brutus does consider Caesar a real friend and this is why he was so sad.
scene 3
1.)Astemidorius' letter represents foreshadowing by stating the names of people who wish to do harm to Caesar. THe audience already knows the plans of the conspiritors but by telling trying to tell Caesar, the audience knows that the plans are going to be carried out soon. The letter shows fate by saying that "if you read this,you might live" because if Caesar does not read it, it would have been his fate to be killed.
Scene 4
1.)Portia is a determined woman and wants to help her husband. She is like most women because she likes gossip and has trouble keeping secrets. In her attempt to find out whats going on she sends her servant to the senate house and just wait and see what happens. She wants the servant to observe whats going on around BRutus to see if he is safe and to make sure his plans are going smoothly.
Scene 1
1. Its saying that he did not do this to fulfill his own desires but it was all for the good of Rome.
2. No it doesn't, I think that he is still and good person who has good motives and is trying to do what is right.
3. He didn't take the oath because he thought swearing shouldn't be the reason for them to do what they need to do their motives alone should be enough.
4. She is worried and confronts him and asks him to tell her what is wrong with him.
Scene 2
1. To show that unpleasant things are approaching them.
2. He persuaded him to go against his wife and leave because if he doesn’t he might not become king.
3. He is upset and feels guilty because he is going to betray his friend and kill him.
Scene 3
1. Because it informs Caesar that Brutus does not love him and to stay away from people if you are not immortal, telling him that people are going to try to kill him.
Scene 4
1. Portia is very worried about Brutus and spies on him. Then she pretends to be aware of all his intentions and plans when she talks to the soothsayer. Portia goes to the soothsayer because she really doesn’t know anything and wants to be informed of Brutus' actual intentions.
ACT II SCENE 1
1.) Act 2 begins with Caesar awake at all hours; the fate of his deceitful deed eating at his soul. In his soliloquy he states that he has no personal feud against Caesar, he is doing what is needed for the sake of Rome and it's people.
2.) No, it doesnt change my view of Brutus. He is a loyal person with the best intentions. His crime is committed not out of hatred but merely out of justice.
3.) Brutus believes that loyalty to Rome and their motives behind killing Caesar should be enough to motivate them. Swearing is cowardly and it should not be the base of their actions.
4.) After noticing that he barely slept and he seemed troubled, she demanded to know what was wrong, but he avoided the subject. She pleaded she had a right to know as his other half, but left dissapointed and worried.
ACT II SCENE 2
1.) The weather shows great significance, in that it foreshadows the darkness ahead. It states that neither the sky nor Earth were silent that night. This resembles the madness soon to come.
2.) After a terrible dream which shes convinced is an omen, Caesars' wife begs he not go out that day. Although when Decius and his devious crew arrive to escort him to the event, they reinterpret the dream to be in his glory. This persuades Caesar that he would be cowardly not to attend, therefore not honoring his wifes wishes.
3.) Brutus' heaart aches in the realization that the person hes about to betray believes him to be a friend.
ACT II SCENE 3
1.) This is merely a warning letter telling Caesar to beware of the people he considers his "friends." Its foreshadowing the people soon to betray him and telling him his fate of being killed.
ACT II SCENE 4
1.) Portia is very concerned about Brutus. She is eager to find out his troubles, so she sends someone to see how he looks at the Senate, if hes well or looks distraught. She is determined to find out his secrets and prove herself as honorable as a man. Portia discusses the mens actions with the soothsayer to calm her worries.
Act 1 Scene 1
1. What does Brutus’ soliloquy show us about his motives for killing Caesar?
Answer: It shows us that Brutus has only wants to kill Caesar to save the Roman govt. “O Rome, I make thee promise / If the redress will follow, thou receivest / Thy full petition at the hand of Brutus!” In the previous three lines, Brutus swears to give Rome justice. The soliliquey shows us that Brutus is not selfish. Unlike Cassius who wants to kill Caesar to obtain more power for himself. Brutus is truly concerned about the welfare of Rome and its people. Through Brutus' actions and his soliliquey you can see that Brutus has good character, is unselfish, and very devoted to his country.
2. Does this change the way you view Brutus? Describe him and discuss your views on his motives for killing Caesar. Is he justified?
Answer: No it doesnt change the way i view him, i still view him as a man with integrity and honor. The soliliquey lets you see how Brutus really thinks and feels. He only is going to kill Caesar because he thinks whole heartedly that he is a threat to Rome.Unlike Cassius who his killing Caesar for selfish and personal reasons Brutus isnt. Brutus only is going to kill Caesar because he really believes that as long as Caesar is alive Rome its people and the Roman empire is in danger.
3. Why does Brutus not want to take an oath with the other conspirators?
Answer: Brutus says that taking an oath is unnecessary because it shouldnt take an oath to motivate you to assassinate Caesar.He says that only men whom you wouldn’t trust anyway would try and swear an oath. He thinks the motivation for killing Caesar should be the people and the reason behind it, not an oath.
4. How does Portia react to Brutus’ strange behavior at the end of the scene?
Answer: She is very concerned about why he has been so withdrawn. She feels that as his wife she has a write to know what is wrong with her husband. She even gets on her knee's and begs him to tell her whats wrong.
Act 2 Scene 2
1. How does the weather reflect what is going on in the play?
Answer: The stormy bad weather with all the thunder and lightning sets you up for a bad event about to take place. Cassius and his group are plotting to kill Caesar and the lightning splitting the skies is also a warning to Caesar. The storm can be used for both a warning to Caesar and the murder of Caesar.
2. Why does Caesar continue to go out despite his wife’s dream?
Answer: He has to keep up this image of a god. He doesnt want to be seen as weak. He is afraid he will be mocked by the senators who are going to give the crown to Caesar that day. If he’d stayed home like his wife said, it would make it seem as if Calphurnia had power of Caesar and wore the pants in that relationship.
3. Why is Brutus sad during his aside towards the end of the scene?
Answer: Brutus is sad because he has finally come to the conclusion that Caesar must die for the sake of Rome. Its hard for Brutus because he liked Caesar and could consider him a friend. Brutus knows he must act like a friend to Caesar, instead of being a true friend because he believes he must kill Caesar.
Act 2 Scene 3
1. How does Artemidorious’ letter represent both foreshadowing by the author and the role fate is playing?
Answer: The letter foreshadows all the people who will kill Caesar. Artemidorious says that if Caesar doesn’t read the letter, fate is on the side of Brutus and the traitors. “ If you read this, O Caesar, thou mayst live / If not, the fates with traitors do contrive.”
Act 2 Scene 4
1. Write a paragraph summarizing Portia’s actions in Scene 4.
Portia has found out what Brutus and the other conspirators are up to. She isn't sure about what they might do but she is worried about harm befalling Caesar. She is so worried that she sends her servant to the capitol just to watch Brutus and Caesar. Portia also asks the soothsayer about the chances of something bad happening to Caesar.
Act 2, Scene 1
1. Brutus said that he had no personal reason to want to kill Caesar. He only wants to do it for the good of Rome. Brutus thinks that Caesar is going to use his power for evil.
2.Yes, this changes my opinion on Brutus very much. When the play started out, I never would of though he was going to want to kill Caesar.. Now I think that Brutus is very much like Cassius. he has no reason for doing what he wants to do..
3.Brutus did not want to take an oath with the other conspirators because he says that if the bad things that are going on in Rome do not concern then, then nothing probably will.
4. She believes that Brutus is hiding something from her,and she told Brutus that she does not feel like a wife, she feels like a whore. She feels that Brutus should be able to tell her everything that goes on.
Act 2, Scene 2
1.In the play it starts raining, and it is also thundering. To me that tells me something bad will happen.
2.Caesar goes out despite of his wife's dream, because Decius tell him about the dream that Calphurnia had. She took the dream in a way that something bad was going to happen to Caesar, but he sees the dream in another way.
3.Brutus is upset because Caesar says "Good friends, go in and have some wine with me. And we'll leave together, like friends." And Brutus took it in a different way that Caesars ment for it to be.
Act 2, Scene 3
1. The letter represents foreshadowing by, making readers think that this note is going to get to Caesar, before time runs out. Fate is coming into this by letting Caesar know that his death is coming.
Act 2, Scene 4
1.Portia acts very concerned for Brutus, and what he is about to do. She sent Lucius to see what was going on and to return immediately to let her know. Then she is asking questions to soothsayer about what he thinks is going to happen. I think she might know what's happening around her, but she's not deffinite yet.
sorry they are late, i was sick and i don't have internet at my house...
Scene 1-
1. he thinks he's doing the right thing for the roman empire
2. he's scared for his friend.
3. he still didn't want to kill his friend.
4. she confronts him.
Scene 2-
1. it's bad weather representing bad times in the future scene.
2. he's testing the gods.
3. caesar believed that Brutus was a friend and loved him like they were brothers.
Scene 3-
1. the letter says that Brutus really doesn't love Caesar.
Scene 4-
1. Lucius is sent to the senate house by Portia, acting very frantic. saying 'i have a mind of a man, but with the strength of a woman."
Act II Scene II
1 Brutus' soliloquy shows that he is doing it for the good of Rome.
2 I personaly see Brutus as people pleaser/gullibul person. He was easily persuaded by Cassius to help in the killing of Caesar. Knowing that Brutus is Loyal to Caesar he was manipulatated into killing Caesar.
3 he thinks that they should already have enough trust in eachother and they need no oaths
4 She is very concerned about him he says that he does not feel well but she knows something other is wrong with him, so she is concerned and angry.
act II scene II
1 all of these strange things such as the weather are setting a mood for the story. It's showing that something strange is about to happen something out of the ordinary.
2 Decius convinces him that his wife interpreted her dream wrong, and that he might loose his chance of getting crowned.
3 He was sad because he has to betray his trust and his loyalty with Caesar. He knows that they were once good friends but now he has to kill a once good friend.
act II sceneII
1 He lists the people that Caesar should not trust, being the people who are trying to kill him. It just shows that he could know what is going on.
act II scene IV
She is worried and unsure of things. She thinks something is going to happen but is not entirely sure of what it might be. She questions the soothsayer and wonders what it means. She can see something is wronge even tho Brutus says nothing is the matter. Yet she is still concerned for him.
1. he thinks his doing it good for rome but he is really nt.
2.it doest cause you rea;;y did not know the guy. his motives were for the good of rome .
3.cause he is kind of scared.
4. trys to comfort thhim about his secerat
scene 2
1.it forshawodes dark times ahead
2.that guy tricks him to by telling him a lie.
3.he does not want to kill ceaser
scene 3
1.forshadowes the killing of himself and fae by helping brutus.
scene 4
1.she thinks something mite happen to ceaser she is wright .
Post a Comment